The Makeover Report: 1,423 Before-and-After Room Makeovers Judged by 6,265 Readers

Cover of The Makeover Report

Report · 55-page PDF + Excel workbook

6,265 readers cast 40,894 votes on 1,423 before-and-after room makeovers (kitchens, living rooms, bedrooms, bathrooms, craft rooms, entries and more): which redesigns win, which colours and styles lose, and why.

  • Instant download after checkout
  • Licensed for use across your company
  • Every figure reproducible from the data
40,894photo votes
6,265readers
1,423photos
9,912reason taps

Redesign the same room many ways and which version do people want? This report scores 1,423 before-and-after makeovers from a US home design publication, each one an AI-generated design visualisation shown below the original room, with nearly every article redesigning one starting room many ways, pools them by style, era, colour temperature, light, wood tone, floor, cabinets, counters, walls and sofa, and adjusts for each article with a same-article index.

Key findings

  • 81% vs 2% hearts for two redesigns of the same builder-grade foyer: French country against a rainbow statement room.
  • 43% vs 19% for warm-toned against cool-toned redesigns; light wood 53%, dark wood 35%.
  • 71% for cream kitchen cabinets, the clearest winner; black 35%, navy 35%.
  • 58% / 32% for farmhouse against modern redesigns; bohemian 22%.

The photos readers loved and rejected

The room makeovers readers loved most

The room makeovers readers rejected most

What’s inside

  • 55-page PDF report
  • Makeovers pooled by style, era, colour temperature, light, wood tone, floor, cabinets, counters, walls and sofa, with 95% ranges and a same-article index
  • The best and worst redesigns of the same room, article by article
  • The most-loved and least-loved makeovers, in pictures, and why readers loved or rejected them
  • What it means for the trade: designers, renovators and flippers, kitchen and surface brands, furniture, paint and decor brands, stagers and realtors, and home media
  • Dataset: Excel workbook (every photo with its traits, pooled traits, articles, reasons)

Sample and method

PanelReaders of homestratosphere.com, a US home design publication
Field windowFeb 19 to Nov 18, 2026
Signals40,894 photo votes from 6,265 readers; 9,912 reason taps
FormatPDF + XLSX, instant download

Readers judged photos, not their own homes. 95% of votes came from the US and 82% from phones; age and gender are not recorded. It is not a national sample.

Who uses this

Interior designers, renovators and flippers, kitchen, cabinet and surface brands, furniture, paint and decor brands, home stagers and realtors, and home media.