The Retro Homes Report: 1,120 Photos of 1950s–1990s Homes Judged by 5,647 Readers

Cover of The Retro Homes Report

Report · 35-page PDF + Excel workbook

5,647 readers cast 32,762 votes on 1,120 photos of 1950s to 1990s homes (kitchens, living rooms, dining rooms, bedrooms, bathrooms and more): which old features they want back, which makeovers work, and why.

  • Instant download after checkout
  • Licensed for use across your company
  • Every figure reproducible from the data
32,762photo votes
5,647readers
1,120photos
7,247reason taps

Which parts of the older American home do readers want back, and how should a dated room be updated? This report scores 1,120 photos from a US home design publication, pools them by cabinet colour, countertop, wood tone, floor, style, era and light, adjusts for each article’s tone with a same-article index, and compares 27 redesigns of the same 1990s oak kitchen.

Key findings

  • 87% vs 14% hearts for two redesigns of the same 1990s oak kitchen: white cabinets with a navy island against black cabinets with a maple island.
  • 96% for rounded counter edges, the top photo with 50+ votes; 12 of the 15 most-loved photos show kitchens, led by practical 1970s features.
  • 34% for engineered wood and vinyl plank floors, the lowest floor; butcher-block counters drew 77%.
  • 66% / 37% for fondly remembered features against then-and-now pairs; “Too cold / stark” is the main complaint on the pairs.

What’s inside

  • 35-page PDF report
  • Retro home photos pooled by cabinet colour, countertop, wood tone, floor, style, era and light, with 95% ranges and a same-article index
  • 27 redesigns of the same 1990s oak kitchen, ranked
  • The most-loved and least-loved features, and why readers loved or rejected them
  • What it means for the trade: designers, renovators and flippers, kitchen, bath and cabinet brands, furniture and decor brands, stagers and realtors, home media
  • Dataset: Excel workbook (every photo with its traits, pooled traits, articles, reasons)

Sample and method

PanelReaders of homestratosphere.com, a US home design publication
Field windowAug 30 to Nov 17, 2026
Signals32,762 photo votes from 5,647 readers; 7,247 reason taps
FormatPDF + XLSX, instant download

Readers judged photos, not their own homes. 98% of votes came from the US and 81% from phones; age and gender are not recorded. It is not a national sample.

Who uses this

Interior designers, renovators and flippers, kitchen, bath and cabinet brands, furniture and decor brands doing retro revivals, home stagers and realtors, and home media.